Alexander’s Guesthouse: Best LGBTQ+ Bed & Breakfast in Key West

Share the Love

Nestled at the southernmost tip of the United States, where the turquoise waters of the Gulf of Mexico meet the Atlantic Ocean, Key West is a paradise for all travelers. But there’s one place in particular that stands out as a welcoming harbor for the LGBTQ+ community and their allies – Alexander’s Guesthouse Key West. With its warm hospitality, unique charm, and commitment to inclusivity, this quaint bed and breakfast has earned its reputation as an LGBTQ-friendly retreat.

Alexander’s Guesthouse is more than just a place to stay; it’s a home away from home for anyone looking to experience the magic of Key West. For over three decades, this delightful retreat has been a haven for LGBTQ+ travelers, offering a safe and supportive environment where guests can truly be themselves.

Nestled in Key West, Florida, Alexander’s Guesthouse offers a tranquil retreat in a welcoming, gay-owned and operated environment. Here, tranquility and relaxation are prioritized, ensuring every guest feels completely at ease within this serene sanctuary.

Location, Location, Location!

Located on Fleming Street, at the heart of Key West’s famous Historic District, Old Town, Alexander’s Guesthouse stands as a convenient starting point for exploring the locale. Guests are just a short walk or bike ride away from gourmet restaurants, theaters, galleries, fine shops, and the lively nightlife that Key West is known for. With only seven “island blocks” to the famous Duval Street, a leisurely 10-minute stroll unveils the historic beauty of Fleming Street, marked by grand mansions and fragrant jasmine trees.

Guesthouse Rooms & Amenities

Alexander’s Guesthouse consists of three meticulously renovated homes, resulting in a total of 17 rooms. Each home, built between 1902-1904, is a testament to the dedication involved in preserving their historical charm. Registered with the Key West Historical Society, the guesthouse has carefully maintained the original details of each home, providing a unique retreat for those who appreciate architectural history.

Alexander's Guesthouse Lobby — Lobby in the Guesthouse Main Entrance. Photo by Rachel Covello

The rooms at Alexander’s Guesthouse, each uniquely decorated in an elegant and contemporary Key West style, offer a blend of modern comforts and historical charm. Although central air conditioning is not available due to the historical nature of the homes, guests will find well-maintained window units in every room.

Guest Room 10 at Alexander’s Guest House. Photo by Rachel Covello

The guesthouse also boasts a variety of amenities for relaxation and socialization. The pool, serving as the social hub of the guesthouse, is surrounded by comfy chairs and lush tropical gardens, providing a perfect setting for relaxation and friendly conversations. Guests can also enjoy a jacuzzi, three levels of sun decks, and a complimentary expanded continental breakfast served poolside. Happy Hour at the Pink Monkey Bar offers complimentary cocktails and a chance to mingle.

Alexander's Guesthouse Pool — Pool at Alexander’s Guesthouse during Womenfest Key West. Photo by Rachel Covello

The guesthouse staff are available to assist with various arrangements, including transportation options like bikes and taxis, as well as offering recommendations and reservations for nightlife and restaurants. The aim is to meet every need during the guests’ stay.

Whether staying at Alexander’s Guesthouse or just visiting Key West, all are invited for a complimentary cocktail and tour during the daily Happy Hour.

Unwavering Community Commitment

One of the cornerstones of Alexander’s Guesthouse is its unwavering commitment to inclusivity and diversity. It proudly embraces guests from all walks of life, regardless of their sexual orientation, gender identity, or background. This dedication to creating a safe and welcoming environment has earned a well-deserved reputation as a true LGBTQ+ safe harbor.

Pride flags hang at Alexander’s Guesthouse in Key West. Photo by Rachel Covello

Throughout the year, Alexander’s participates in, supports and hosts various LGBTQ+ events and initiatives on the island. From Pride celebrations to fundraisers for LGBTQ+ charities, they are deeply involved in the Key West LGBTQ+ community. This active engagement ensures that guests feel not only welcomed but also connected to the larger LGBTQ+ family.

Book Your Stay in Key West at Alexander’s Guesthouse

In the heart of Key West’s welcoming embrace, Alexander’s Guesthouse stands out as a true gem, offering LGBTQ+ travelers and their allies a place of comfort, community, and inclusivity. Whether you’re lounging by the pool, exploring the island’s spirited nightlife, or simply enjoying the company of fellow travelers, this charming bed and breakfast ensures that your Key West experience is as memorable as it is authentic.

With its warm and friendly staff, beautiful accommodations, and unwavering commitment to inclusivity, Alexander’s Guesthouse Key West is more than just a place to stay; it’s a destination in itself. It’s where friendships are forged, memories are made, and a sense of belonging is nurtured, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking an unforgettable Key West adventure. So, pack your bags, leave your worries behind, and let Alexander’s Guesthouse be your home away from home in Key West’s LGBT-friendly oasis.

While you enjoy your stay, explore some of these great Florida Key destinations.

**Disclaimer: There is a good chance that this post contains affiliate or sponsor links. If you make a purchase through them, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you (for which we are extremely grateful).

Also, while we do our best to highlight LGBTQ-friendly destinations and businesses, info provided is based solely on personal experience and recommendations by community partners. We hope that nobody experiences discrimination or homophobia while visiting Florida, but we make no guarantees. Please inform us if you experience discrimination or homophobia while visiting any destination so we can make updates to our recommendations.

Rachel Covello

Rachel Covello is an award-winning speaker, writer, diversity consultant, and LGBT advocate. She was the Founder of LGBT Equality Alliance, a Chester County, PA nonprofit organization. She is currently the Publisher of OutCoast.com and Producer of the OutCoast TV YouTube Channel, both of which highlight LGBTQ welcoming destinations in Florida.

View All Post By Rachel Covello