Savoring LGBTQ+ Inclusivity: Key West’s Top Restaurants

Share the Love

In Key West, it’s not just a beautiful tropical paradise; it’s also a place that welcomes and accepts everyone, including the LGBTQ+ community. Discover the top restaurants in Key West that embody the island’s open-minded spirit, inviting you to savor both delicious food and a strong sense of belonging.

Off the Hook Bar & Grill

Situated in the heart of Key West, you’ll find Off the Hook Bar & Grill, a place that captures the flavors of Florida Keys cuisine. This restaurant is friendly and open to seafood lovers, and it also supports the LGBTQ+ community.

Here, you can enjoy a variety of seafood dishes, from fresh catches to tasty shellfish, all prepared like culinary works of art. They also have options for those who prefer land-based food. While you sip on skillfully made cocktails, you can take in the breathtaking Gulf of Mexico sunset views. Off the Hook is a must-visit in Key West, offering seafood as fresh as the ocean breeze.

Blue Heaven

Nestled in the heart of Bahama Village, Blue Heaven is a must-visit eatery for locals and tourists alike. This iconic restaurant oozes charm and offers a delightful dining experience.

Blue Heaven is renowned for its mouthwatering Caribbean-inspired cuisine and its equally appealing atmosphere.

Their outdoor courtyard, framed by lush vegetation and dotted with funky artwork, is a favorite spot among LGBTQ+ visitors. Live music adds to the ambiance, creating a lively and inclusive environment that welcomes all. Don’t miss their famous Key Lime pie – it’s legendary!

Mangoes

To experience the true essence of Key West, head to Mangoes, a waterfront restaurant offering a taste of the tropics. This restaurant celebrates LGBTQ+ inclusivity, creating an environment where all patrons are treated with respect and warmth.

The menu at Mangoes highlights Caribbean and Floridian flavors. Start with conch fritters or coconut-crusted shrimp, followed by blackened mahi-mahi or jerk chicken. And, of course, don’t forget to save room for dessert; Mangoes’ Key lime pie is a sweet and tangy delight.

Food from Mangoes Key West — Photo by Rachel Covello

La Te Da

La Te Da isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a fabulous experience. This historic Key West establishment combines a boutique hotel, a cabaret, and a delectable dining spot all in one. The restaurant’s outdoor terrace, surrounded by swaying palms, creates an enchanting backdrop for your meal.

La Te Da has long been an LGBTQ+ hub, hosting drag shows and performances that celebrate diversity. Their menu is equally impressive, featuring a fusion of flavors from around the world, ensuring there’s something for every palate.

Louie’s Backyard

Louie’s Backyard is a gem among Key West’s LGBTQ+ inclusive restaurants. Located on the quieter side of Duval Street, this restaurant boasts stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. The menu is a culinary journey through New American cuisine, with a focus on fresh seafood and locally sourced ingredients.

What makes Louie’s Backyard truly special is its oceanfront dining deck, which offers a serene setting. It’s the perfect spot for a special occasion or a romantic dinner date with breathtaking sunsets as your backdrop.

Smokin’ Tuna Saloon

The Smokin’ Tuna Saloon is all about great seafood and a relaxed atmosphere. You’ll find it right in the heart of the historic Old Town, and it’s a hit with both locals and tourists. Their menu is full of fresh catches and delicious Southern-inspired dishes. Plus, they have a cozy outdoor patio where you can savor your meal.

If you’re looking for a chill place to enjoy fantastic seafood, the Smokin’ Tuna is a top choice and one of the best places to catch local music, especially country music. And their tuna nachos (pictured) might be one of my favorite dishes on the island.

Nachos from Smokin' Tuna Saloon — Photos by Rachel Covello

Azur Restaurant

Azur Restaurant is a Mediterranean-inspired gem that has become a beloved spot for LGBTQ+ diners in Key West. Located on the quieter end of Duval Street, this restaurant is known for its fresh and inventive dishes that celebrate Mediterranean flavors.

The restaurant’s chic interior and attentive staff provide a relaxed and inviting atmosphere for LGBTQ+ visitors and locals alike. Whether you’re indulging in their famous Mediterranean-style brunch or savoring dinner on their tranquil patio, you’re sure to enjoy a memorable meal.

Nine One Five

Nine One Five is a trendy eatery that seamlessly combines sophistication with a laid-back vibe. Situated in a stunning old Victorian house, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience. The menu features a mix of American and Mediterranean flavors, providing a plethora of options for patrons.

Nine One Five is all about being open and accepting. You can see it in how the staff treats everyone, including LGBTQ+ individuals. The restaurant’s cozy interior and intimate courtyard make it an excellent choice for a romantic evening or a fun night out with friends.

Banana Café

For a French culinary experience in the heart of Key West, make your way to Banana Café. This charming eatery is renowned for its delicious breakfast and brunch options, as well as its intimate setting that transports you to a cozy Parisian café.

Banana Café’s LGBTQ+ inclusive environment has made it a cherished establishment in the community. The staff is known for their friendliness, and the restaurant frequently hosts themed events and drag brunches that are not only entertaining but also create a fabulous atmosphere.

Conch Republic Seafood Company

The Conch Republic Seafood Company is a spot where you’ll find delicious Caribbean-inspired cuisine. This island eatery has a come-as-you-are vibe and serves up fresh seafood with tropical flavors. It’s the go-to place for enjoying a laid-back meal while embracing the island’s easygoing charm.

The Conch Republic, although huge and a tad touristy, brings in fresh seafood daily. They even have their own boats and fishmongers who filet the fish prior to serving. It’s also one of the best places to get Florida lobster during lobster season.

Clams at Conch Republic Seafood Company — Photos by Rachel Covello

Lobster at Conch Republic Seafood Company — Photos by Rachel Covello

La Trattoria

If you’re a fan of Italian food, you won’t want to miss out on La Trattoria. This delightful restaurant, located on Duval Street, brings a slice of Italy to the heart of Key West. Their menu is full of classic Italian dishes, from pasta to seafood, all crafted with care and precision.

La Trattoria is known for its LGBTQ+ inclusive atmosphere, which is clear from the diverse mix of people who dine there and the staff. The outdoor patio is a lovely spot to enjoy your Italian meal, creating a pleasant setting for a leisurely dining experience.

Santiago’s Bodega

For tapas and wine enthusiasts, Santiago’s Bodega is a slice of palate-pleasing heaven. Located just a short walk from Duval Street, this cozy restaurant offers an array of small plates perfect for sharing. The eclectic menu is a true testament with options to accommodate various dietary preferences.

The friendly atmosphere at Santiago’s Bodega is evident as soon as you step inside. The staff is known for their warmth and attentiveness, making every guest feel like family. It’s a fantastic spot for LGBTQ+ travelers seeking delicious food and good company.

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar

To indulge in the flavors of the American South in Key West, Alonzo’s Oyster Bar is the place to be. This restaurant offers a one-of-a-kind menu that includes Southern classics with a modern twist. From fried chicken to shrimp and grits, their culinary offerings are sure to please.

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar’s cozy interior and friendly staff welcomes LGBTQ+ visitors and locals alike. The restaurant’s commitment to acceptance shines through, making it a fantastic choice for comfort food and good company.

Embrace Key West’s Inclusive Dining Scene

Key West’s culinary scene is as diverse and inclusive as the island itself. These LGBTQ+ friendly restaurants offer not only delicious food but also warm and welcoming environments where everyone can feel at home. Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening, a casual brunch, or a meal with friends, these eateries have something to satisfy every craving and celebrate the spirit of inclusivity that makes Key West so special. Don’t miss the opportunity to indulge in great food while immersing yourself in the island’s rich culture of acceptance and diversity.

Be sure to check out our guide on the Top 7 Things to Do in Key West and don’t hit the road without these essential travel tips for exploring the Florida Keys!

**Disclaimer: There is a good chance that this post contains affiliate or sponsor links. If you make a purchase through them, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you (for which we are extremely grateful).

Also, while we do our best to highlight LGBTQ-friendly destinations and businesses, info provided is based solely on personal experience and recommendations by community partners. We hope that nobody experiences discrimination or homophobia while visiting Florida, but we make no guarantees. Please inform us if you experience discrimination or homophobia while visiting any destination so we can make updates to our recommendations.

Fay Stevenson

Originally from Baltimore, Fay started her career as an elementary school Language Arts teacher. Five years later, Fay joined Johnson & Johnson where she enjoyed a 31-year career in pharmaceutical sales. After a move to Florida following her retirement, Fay joined the OutCoast team to bring the first Florida OutCoast Convention (FLOCC) to the Tampa Bay Area. Fay is living her best life in St Petersburg. In her spare time, Fay is an amateur singer/songwriter and avid sports fan.

View All Post By Fay Stevenson